Career Penalty Minutes
1988-89 thru 1997-98
| Player |
Penalty |
| Fassbender | 323 |
| Hendricks | 302 |
| Silvester | 290 |
| Watson, Andy | 280 |
| Surowiec | 256 |
| Phelps | 235 |
| Majetic | 233 |
| Moran | 225 |
| Bunch | 216 |
| Royston | 200 |
| Goleniak | 187 |
| Genotti | 173 |
| Kass | 167 |
| Ruffing | 159 |
| Vosnick | 159 |
| Berry | 159 |
| Kelm, Pat | 157 |
| Grondin | 156 |
| Williams, Brett | 155 |
| Breach | 149 |
| Chiles | 144 |
| Titus | 143 |
| Watson, Rob | 141 |
| Donnelly | 132 |
| Morrell | 130 |
| Perino | 126 |
| Geelhood | 119 |
| Brass | 117 |
| Boal | 115 |
| Shaberly | 114 |
| Dunn | 110 |
| Johnson | 109 |
| Nelson | 108 |
| Krolik, Phil | 108 |
| Mitter | 105 |
| Devine | 103 |
| Cusumano, Joe | 102 |
| Mueller | 102 |
| Tompkins | 90 |
| Jardine | 89 |
| Beltz | 86 |
| Farmer | 84 |
| Kivi | 82 |
| Frey | 82 |
| Zvoch | 81 |
| Eller, Mike | 80 |
| Hartman | 76 |
| Spirl | 74 |
| McHugh | 71 |
| Ransom | 70 |
| Hawley | 70 |
| Schaecher | 58 |
| Luft | 50 |
| Gilbert | 49 |
| O'Brien | 46 |
| Garcia | 46 |
| Niemi | 44 |
| Blum | 44 |
| Hudson | 44 |
| Lally | 42 |
| Kubitskey | 39 |
| Cobello | 37 |
| Godre | 35 |
| Rowe | 34 |
| Sheedy | 32 |
| Patterson | 28 |
| Kellerman | 24 |
| Lawver | 24 |
| Pientack | 22 |
| Kelm, Rob | 22 |
| Rumple | 19 |
| Massey | 18 |
| Ward | 17 |
| Decina | 16 |
| Robson | 16 |
| Cusumano, Tony | 14 |
| Radford | 14 |
| Lippert | 10 |
| Hembree | 6 |
| Boyd | 6 |
| Herbst | 4 |
| Katus | 4 |
| Smyth | 4 |
| Williams, Lon | 4 |
| Cole | 0 |